Skip to content
This English version of the site was translated with AI assistance. We apologise for any errors and are working to improve it.
Seudat Mitzvah, or How to Silence the Accuser
Mitzvah

Seudat Mitzvah, or How to Silence the Accuser

Seudat Mitzvah, or How to Silence the Accuser

A Jewish man asked that the Maggid of Chernobyl be the sandak at his son's brit.

The Maggid asked, “Will there be a seudat mitzvah after the Brit Milah?”

The man replied that he was very poor and could not afford to host a meal. The Maggid said, “If you want me to be the sandak, you must promise that you will observe the custom and host a seudah.” He advised him to borrow money from his employer.

The Maggid explained: “The angel of Esau is Sama-el, and this is an acronym for the words:

סעודה מילה אין לעשות

‘Seudah milah—ein la'asot’—(not to make a brit milah meal).

That is, when broken down by its letters:

סעודה ס Seudah (meal)

מילה מ Milah (circumcision / Brit Milah)

אין א Ein (cannot, not)

לעשות ל La'asot (to do).

The yetzer hara does everything in its power to prevent us from hosting these three particular meals. Unfortunately, when it comes to a siyum (the meal held after completing the study of a tractate of the Talmud or a section of Mishnah), it often succeeds. But I will not let it stop us from hosting a meal after the brit, which is why I insist on this.”

“Bat Ayin”—Rabbi Avraham Dov of Ovruch was present during this conversation. Some time later, he explained why Satan cannot tolerate meals celebrating the completion of a tractate, a Brit Milah, or other special mitzvot.

Satan appears before the L-rd and says: “So-and-so committed this transgression, and another committed that transgression.” The angel Michael immediately responds: “Look at the broken heart of the person—even when he sinned, he did not want to do so. But look at the Jew who completed a tractate, fulfilled a mitzvah, or performed a brit milah for his son. How happy he is! He even hosted a feast to rejoice in his fortunate lot!”

This argument silences Satan. That is why he tries so hard to prevent us from hosting a seudat mitzvah.

(Based on “The Well of Torah” on “Behar” by Rabbi Elimelech Biderman)

Was this helpful?

100% of readers found this article helpful (34 votes).

Please note: some articles on our site contain the holy Names of the Almighty. If you print these articles, they may not be thrown away or destroyed. Please handle printed copies with care and respect.

Tags: Seudah, Seudat Mitzvah, or How to Silence the Accuser, Seudat mitzvah, Mitzvah

18 May 2026
Share

Related articles